Government solvency, austerity and fiscal consolidation in the oecd. The transversality condition is a necessary condition for the vanishing of the first variation of a functional. This paper shows that the standard transversality condition stvc is necessary for optimality in stochastic models with bounded or constantrelativerisk aversion crra utility under fairly general conditions. That is, households can borrow and lend in the international. Borrowing constraints, noponzi conditions, and intertemporal budget constraints are all inequalities, bounding debt or net worth from below. Completed bydavid cass 1965andtjalling koopmans 1965.
The importance of transversality conditions more on the ramsey model. This principally because, as note previously, optimal control theory does allow for corner solution, which are points at which the hamiltonian is not di erentiable. In this section, we start the analysis of the neoclassical growth model by considering the opti. Sciences po graduate macroeconomics 1 problem set 2 question 1 the transversality condition consider the following problem. Slides for chapter 3 an intertemporal theory of the current. X t 0 c tk 0 notice that there is only one lifetime feasibility constraint, with multiplier 2.
The importance of transversality conditions more on the. Phase diagram see graph that i drew in lecture by hand or figure 8. The maxim um principle hamiltonian the hamiltonian is a useful recip e to solv e. The transversality condition says that the discounted value of. Omer ozak smu economic growth macroeconomics ii 4 47. We build entirely on models with microfoundations, i.
The transversality condition 20 pins down the initial level of consumption c 0. Equation 5 is a typical transversality condition in economics. By generalizing benveniste and scheinkmans 1982 envelope condition and michels 1990 version of the squeezing argument, we show a generalization of michels 1990, theorem 1 necessity result that does not assume concavity. This paper investigates the relevance of the noponzi game condition for public debt i. The npg condition does not contemplates the subjective marginal utility of the. Are noponzi game and transversality conditions relevant. T 0 transversality condition 6 notice that the rst, rst order condition with respect to the control variable is not stated as a derivative. And this is the same interpretation of the so called transversality condition. Necessity of the transversality condition for stochastic. Macroeconomics iii frederik mun ter where q t r 0 r 1 r t 1 is the opportunity cost of consumption in utility terms at time t.
Advanced macroeconomics the ramsey model micha l brzozabrzezinamarcin kolasa. One can show that the aforementioned transversality condition is both necessary and su cient. Transversality conditions are optimality conditions often used along. The noponzi game condition henceforth the npg condition on public andor private debt which also stands for a transversality condition for debt eliminates the possibility of a ponzi chain letter. Transversality conditions are optimality conditions often used along with euler equations to characterize the optimal paths of dynamic economic models. Jun 29, 2015 the importance of transversality conditions more on the ramsey model there has been some fun and interesting discussion of the ramseycasskoopmans rck model on this post of mine. Since shell 1969 and halkin 1974, necessity of transversality conditions tvcs has been an uneasy matter to economic theorists who use in. Since the euler equation 3 and the transversality condition 5 are. Graduate macroeconomics 1 tutorial 2 problem set 2. Growth model, dynamic optimization in discrete time. The second condition means that the marginal rate of intertemporal substitution in consumption equals the marginal capital of capital net of depreciation plus one. That is why some times it is known as the ramsey model. T has often been called a transversality condition, for historical reasons deriving from timeoptimal problems, where the variable time t to reach a target is minimized.
Transversality condition and the end of period condition. Modelfree tests in housing markets by stefano giglio,matteo maggiori, and johannes stroebel1 we test for the existence of housing bubbles associated with a failure of the transver. This article explains the foundations of transversality conditions using a geometric example, a. Examples of strong transversality conditions inspired by finite horizon conditions. One might think that the consumers budget constraint 2 is an additional equation. Transversality condition encyclopedia of mathematics. This paper shows that the standard transversality condition stvc is necessary for optimality in stochastic models with bounded or constantrelativerisk aversion crra utility under fairly. While much of this is done as a decision rule problem of the rm, it is easily incorporated into a general equilibrium structure. When written with the equal sign, this condition can be interpreted as the willingness of not keeping any capital at the end of life. Equation 5 is a typical transversality condition in economics, but it is. The reason why we may need the transversality condition is that the rstorder conditions only determine what is optimal from period to period, but might ignore the overall picture. Potential consequences of linear approximation in economics. Initial bondstate variable condition problem is discussed also.
Final good sector similar to before, but assumptions 1 and 2 are not satis ed. Government solvency, austerity and fiscal consolidation in. Transversality condition this limits the npg condition in optimum such that lim t. Introduction neoclassical growth model original contribution oframsey 1928. Notes on investment eric sims university of notre dame spring 2011 1 introduction these notes introduce and discuss modern theories of rm investment. The tvc is a condition for optimization, in most economic models playing the role of ruling out solutions in which wealth grows rapidly. Sorry to those in the discussion that i havent gotten back to the comments yet ive been taking my time to think about whats been brought up. Second, the noponzi and the transversality conditions were more frequent in the. Fortunately, the transversality condition helps us here. In the ramsey model, agents or the dictator choose consumption and investment optimally so as to maximize their individual utility or social welfare. Indeterminacy of ramsey model under heterogeneous time.
This paper studies necessity of transversality conditions for the continuous time, reduced form model. Transversality conditions and dynamic economic behaviour. However, if we substitute the market clearing condition 7 into the consumers budget constraint, the consumers budget constraint and the. The nature of the transversality condition depends greatly on the statement of the problem. The most standard tvc, which we call the standard tvc stvc, is the condition that the value of optimal stocks at in.
The transversality condition for an infinite hori zon dynamic. No ponzi game condition and transversality condition are the. Are noponzi game and transversality conditions relevant for. Macroeconomic theory i benjamin moll princeton university fall 2014. Lecture notes for macroeconomics i, 2004 yale economic. Lecture notes in the solow model, agents in the economy or the dictator follow a simplistic linear rule for con sumption and investment. A necessary condition for optimality in variational problems with variable endpoints. Transversality the transversality condition is an optimality condition, not a constraint. Thus, is it right to interpret the no ponzi game condition as a finite horizon version of the transversality condition. Growth model, dynamic optimization in discrete time eco 503. In other macroeconomic topics, such as monetary economics, labor. Transversality condition ensures individual would never want to have positive wealth asymptotically, so noponzigame condition can be strengthened to though not necessary in general. Transversality conditions and dynamic economic behavior. In that situation, the transversality condition appears as a description of how the optimal path crosses a terminal line graphing state.
Advanced macroeconomics the ramsey model micha l brzozabrzezinamarcin kolasa warsaw school of economics. A keynesian appraisal of transversality and no ponzi game conditions karim azizi1, nicolas canry2, jeanbernard chatelain3, bruno tinel4 april 24th, 20 abstract. The transversality condition can be obtained by taking the limit of 1. The necessity of the transversality condition at in nity.
Necessity of transversality conditions for infinite horizon. Solutions question 1 the transversality condition 1. The arbitrary constants on which the solution of the euler equation depends are determined by means of the tranversality condition. The emphasis is on theory, although data guides the theoretical explorations. The issues regarding new keynesian transversality condition is also discussed, on whether zero output gap convergence can economicswise be maintained. Transversality condition is a bit mysterious best treatments are in various papers by kamihigashi most intuitive transversality conditions and dynamic. A transversality condition describes what must be satisfied at the end of the time horizon.
1351 1241 178 754 691 735 702 395 966 729 1155 101 1212 647 1393 1293 187 347 972 37 1500 624 90 700 581 860 917 1463 161 1430 1263 769 567 1308 1055 526 26 970 255 1374 706 385